The Nader Sisters Reveal Whether They’re on Santa’s Naughty or Nice List This Year

Who do you think will make the cut?

Sarah Jane, Mary Holland, Brooks and Grace Ann Nader. / Jason Howard/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images/Getty Images

We are one week out from Christmas, which means Santa’s official naughty and nice lists are getting their final touches before the big night. Where do the Nader sisters—Brooks, Mary Holland, Grace Ann and Sarah Jane—fall on this year’s list? Well, the Love Thy Nader stars made their predictions on Instagram on Wednesday, Dec. 17, ahead of the iHeartRadio Jingle Ball, which aired on ABC that same night.

“We’re at Jingle Ball, and of course, we're on the naughty list!” The sisters exclaimed in unison to begin the 21-second reel. The group of sisters then declared their statuses individually in the joint post between iHeartJingleBall, ABC, Love Thy Nader and Freeform.

View this post on Instagram

“I’m Grace Ann, and of course, I’m on the naughty list,” the second-youngest sister exclaimed, starting off the group. Then came fellow middle sister, Mary Holland, who took an opposite stance: “Of course I’m on the nice list,” she stated following her own introduction.

“I’m Brooks, and of course I’m on the nice list,” the eldest Nader declared next—although the sentiment was met with immediate backlash from the rest of the sisters, who rebutted with a slew of “naughtys.” To end the clip, the youngest sister, Sarah Jane, said that she was on “both lists” and stuck to her choice in the post’s comment section, penning “#Bothlists.”

While the short and playful reel was posted on Wednesday, the sisters seemed to have forecasted their standings on the festive roster during iHeartRadio Z100’s Jingle Ball 2025 in Manhattan. The show, which commenced on Dec. 12, showcased a star-studded lineup of hitmakers, including Ed Sheeran, Nelly, Reneé Rapp and more.

Mary Holland, Brooks, Grace Ann and Sarah Jane Nader / Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty Images/iHeartRadio

The sisters also sported some of their most festive attire of the holiday season while in attendance at Madison Square Garden. We previously covered their looks—ranging from Brooks’s speckled, lace-trim mini dress to Sarah Jane’s jewel-toned leather bodysuit here!

Plus, if you missed Wednesday night’s show—which originally aired on ABC at 8 ET—no need to fret. Its entire lineup of performances is released on Hulu today, Dec. 18, so you can ring in the last days of 2025 with your favorite artists.

View this post on Instagram

The tour also has a duo of stops before wrapping up for the new year. Today, it will touch down at Atlanta’s State Farm Arena, before heading south to Miami’s Kaseya Center for its final show on Dec. 20.

For more SI Lifestyle content directly in your Google feed, add us as preferred source here!

---

More Lifestyle & Celeb:

feed