Brooks Nader and Her Sisters Say ‘Love Thy Nader’ Season 2 Will Be ‘More Unhinged’

The siblings walked the iHeartRadio Jingle Ball 2025 red carpet in style before giving fans some insight into the second season of their hit reality show.

Grace Ann Nader, Brooks Nader, Mary Holland Nader and Sarah Jane Nader / XNY/Star Max/GC Images/Getty Images

The Nader sisters—Brooks, Grace Ann, Mary Holland and Sarah Jane—who starred in this year’s breakout hit reality TV series Love Thy Nader, attended the 2025 Jingle Ball at Madison Square Garden in New York City on Friday, Dec. 13, where they gave fans some hints at what the highly anticipated second season might have in store.

Overall, one word seemed to embody the vibe of their sophomore season, per the sisters themselves—and that word was: “unhinged.”

View this post on Instagram

Celebrating Season 2

While walking the red carpet for the annual holiday event, the sisters stopped for an interview with Deuxmoi. There, the outlet asked what fans everywhere have been wondering about their hit Hulu show, which was just renewed for a second season in late November: “What can we expect from Season 2 of Love Thy Nader?”

“If I told you, I’d have to kill you—no, I’m just kidding,” Brooks joked to start the interview as her sisters laughed. “I feel like we take things to a whole entirely new level in Season 2. And we’re not allowed to reveal much legally, but we reveal all new sides of ourselves to the world, and new, interesting characters are in the mix [...] we will not disappoint. There are new players in the game.”

The interviewer then asked the sisters to each answer the question: “What’s the difference between Season 1 you and Season 2 you?” Sarah Jane started, commenting on each of their “growth” during the first season before stating, “Season 2, we’re going into it, like, very unhinged and just, like, totally ourselves because we’re not nervous at all.”

Brooks then quipped off-mic that she thought they “already were [unhinged]” in the first season, to which Sarah Jane added: “If you can imagine more unhinged, it’s that.”

Mary Holland Nader, Brooks Nader, Grace Ann Nader and Sarah Jane Nader / Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images for iHeartRadio

Styling & glam

Aside from the peek into their Season 2 plans, the sisters also brought plenty of their signature Nader style to the red carpet, with each wearing a fabulous holiday-ready look. While all of their ensembles expertly fit their individual styles, there was still a clear theme among the four: strapless necklines, mini cuts and sheer black tights.

Brooks revived one of this summer’s most popular trends—polka dots—with her speckled cream mini dress, which she paired with pointed-toe stilettos. Sarah Jane opted for a sweet romper crafted from a shiny, Y2K-style fabric in a lush forest green shade. Grace Ann kept the holiday vibes going strong with a crimson bodysuit with plenty of sparkling sequins. And Mary Holland kept it classic with a black mini dress featuring a pop of cherry-red around the neckline and dual pockets.

While there is currently no official premiere date for Love Thy Nader Season 2 at the time of this article’s publication, all eight episodes of the breakout first season are currently available to stream on Hulu!

---

More Lifestyle & Celeb:

feed